Andy Richter Voted Off ‘Dancing With the Stars’ — Viewers Call It the “Biggest Upset” of Season 34

Andy Richter’s journey on Dancing With the Stars came to an emotional end during the show’s 20th birthday party episode on November 11, 2025.

The comedian’s elimination shocked viewers, with many calling it the “biggest upset” of Season 34. Despite consistently low scores, Richter had become a beloved underdog, saved week after week by his loyal fanbase, the “Fandies.”

The Dance That Ended His Run

Richter and his professional partner Emma Slater performed a lively Quickstep to Robbie Williams’ “Puttin’ on the Ritz.”

The routine earned them 29 out of 40 points, the lowest score of the night. Judge Carrie Ann Inaba gave them an 8, while guest judge Tom Bergeron and the other panelists each awarded 7s.

The Upset That Shocked Fans

For weeks, Richter’s fan support had carried him through eliminations, despite lower scores. But this time, the combination of judges’ marks and audience votes sealed his fate.

Viewers flooded social media with emotional reactions, calling his exit “heartbreaking” and “the biggest shock of the season.”

Andy Richter’s Emotional Farewell

After the elimination, Richter expressed heartfelt gratitude. “It’s changed my life. I’m a different person because of this show and because of this woman right here [Emma Slater]. None of this would have happened without her,” he said.

Fans praised his humility and emotional honesty, cementing his underdog journey as one of the most memorable in DWTS history.

A Night of Celebrations and Perfect Scores

The milestone episode wasn’t just about Richter’s exit. Four contestants earned perfect scores of 40 out of 40, setting a new record for the series.

The six couples advancing to the semi-finals on November 18, 2025 are Alix Earle, Elaine Hendrix, Jordan Chiles, Dylan Efron, Whitney Leavitt, and Robert Irwin. With a Prince tribute night ahead, the competition for the Mirrorball Trophy is heating up.

Andy Richter’s elimination may have shocked fans, but his heartfelt journey proved the power of resilience, fan support, and emotional connection on Dancing With the Stars.