Cowboys Consider Trading Mazi Smith Ahead of Deadline

The Dallas Cowboys are reportedly exploring trade options for defensive tackle Mazi Smith as the NFL trade deadline approaches. This marks the first public indication that the team may part ways with its 2023 first-round draft pick. Smith has appeared in just five games this season, and internal competition has raised questions about his long-term role. With the deadline looming on Tuesday, Dallas faces a critical decision regarding the underperforming lineman.

The Cowboys are evaluating trade possibilities for Mazi Smith, a former first-round pick, ahead of the NFL’s trade deadline on Tuesday, November 5, 2025. The move comes amid limited production from Smith and the emergence of other defensive tackles on the roster. Discussions are taking place at the team’s headquarters in Frisco, Texas, as Dallas weighs whether to trade or potentially release the 24-year-old lineman.

Player Status and Roster Dynamics

• Smith has played in only 5 games this season
• Perrion Winfrey has outperformed expectations following a strong preseason
• Rookie Jay Toia is viewed as a long-term developmental asset
• Smith was once labeled Bruce Feldman’s “Freakiest Athlete” in college football
• He has worked under three different defensive coordinators since joining the team

Smith’s most productive stretch came under Mike Zimmer and defensive line coach Jeff Zgonina, but consistent impact has been lacking.

Reactions: Analyst and Team Commentary

Team insiders suggest the Cowboys are disappointed with Smith’s progression. NFL analyst Todd Archer noted, “It’s rare for Dallas to move on from a first-rounder this early, but the depth chart and performance metrics don’t lie.” If released, Smith would be the first Cowboys first-round pick cut before completing his rookie deal since Taco Charlton in 2019.

Defensive Depth and Draft Strategy

Trading or releasing Smith would reflect a shift in the Cowboys’ defensive strategy. The team has invested heavily in interior line depth, and Smith’s departure could open more reps for Toia and Winfrey. It also raises questions about recent draft evaluations and the team’s ability to develop high-potential prospects.

What’s Next: Deadline Moves and Roster Implications

The Cowboys have until 4 PM ET on Tuesday to finalize any trade involving Smith. If no deal materializes, a release remains possible. Dallas will continue to assess its defensive rotation ahead of a pivotal Week 10 matchup. The front office is expected to prioritize roster flexibility and performance-based decisions.