Jonathan Bailey and David Corenswet Break the Internet With Musical Exchange

Jonathan Bailey and David Corenswet are taking the internet by storm after their recent pairing on Variety’s popular series Actors on Actors. The episode, which featured the two stars discussing their latest blockbuster roles, quickly became a trending topic across social media due to the duo’s striking chemistry and playful musical exchange.

Bailey, who recently delivered notable performances in Wicked: For Good and Jurassic World Rebirth, sat down with Corenswet, the new face of James Gunn’s Superman reboot. Their conversation explored the creative process behind their latest work, the pressure of global attention, and the enduring magic of musical theatre.

Behind-the-Scenes Clip Sparks Fan Frenzy

Interest skyrocketed after Variety released behind-the-scenes footage showing Bailey and Corenswet bonding over an unexpected shared dream role: starring in a musical adaptation of High Society. Upon discovering their mutual admiration for the production, the pair spontaneously broke into song—an unscripted moment that fans found irresistibly charming.

Social media reaction was immediate and overwhelmingly enthusiastic, with viewers praising the joyful, authentic energy exchanged between the actors. One YouTube commenter wrote, “They match each other’s theatrical nerd energy so well it’s crazy, I’m obsessed.” Another viewer commented, “Their chemistry is so insane they break into harmonies like it’s muscle memory — Broadway, come collect your duo already.”

A fan on X (formerly Twitter) pushed the idea even further, suggesting the duo be cast together: “All teenage boys should be required to watch this. THIS is how two loving, fun, talented men talk to each other.”

Fans Call for Broadway Casting — and Even a Batman Proposal

The viral moment has also fueled more creative fan conversations, including fancasting proposals. One commentator joked that Bailey should be cast as Batman opposite Corenswet’s Superman: “F**k it man, have Jonathan be Batman, the chemistry is there and it’s bouncing off the walls.” Fancasting Bailey in the role of the Caped Crusader gained traction in late 2024, especially after filmmaker James Gunn reportedly liked a social post supporting the idea. Bailey himself playfully acknowledged the speculation last month on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon.

With momentum building rapidly online, fans are calling on Broadway and Hollywood alike to reunite the charismatic pair—perhaps for a future musical collaboration or a comic-book crossover. For now, their Actors on Actors clip continues to surge across platforms, proving once again the powerful appeal of authentic, joyful creative chemistry.