Makes The Bottom Of The Barrel Look Like Everest’ – Critics Roast Playdate’s Alan Ritchson & Kevin James

Amazon Prime Video’s latest action-comedy, Playdate, starring Alan Ritchson and Kevin James, is facing harsh criticism ahead of its release. Streaming critics describe the film as lacking energy, wit, and coherence, with one review stating it “makes the bottom of the barrel look like Everest.” While the buddy-comedy duo shows occasional chemistry, reviewers largely pan the movie’s humor, plot, and overall execution. Despite negative critical reception, some audience members appear to enjoy the lighthearted action and interactions between Ritchson and James. Playdate is now available for streaming on Prime Video.

Plot & Cast

Playdate follows an odd-couple action-comedy formula, with Alan Ritchson, known for Reacher, Aquaman, and Hawk, pairing with veteran comedian Kevin James. Supporting roles include Isla Fisher, Sarah Chalke, and Alan Tudyk. Critics note the film’s humor is juvenile, leaning heavily on slapstick, shouting, and crude jokes, often failing to balance action and comedy. The movie runs under 90 minutes, featuring zany sequences, energy drinks-fueled children, and over-the-top stunts.

Critical Reactions

Reviews have been overwhelmingly negative. Decider’s John Serba remarks that the dialogue is mostly “casually naughty nonsense” with limited cinematic merit. THR critic Frank Scheck calls it a “compendium of clichés in search of one,” while Paste’s Jim Vorel labels the movie “vastly irritating and downright embarrassing.” AV Club’s Matt Donato criticizes it as disrespectful to audiences and devoid of humor.

In contrast, CBR’s Nicholas Brooks gives the film a 6/10 rating, praising the chemistry between Ritchson and James. He notes that while the comedy misfires at times, the duo’s dynamic offers redeeming entertainment value for viewers seeking a lightweight, at-home action-comedy experience.

Critical vs Audience Reception

Critics’ consensus currently holds Playdate at a 19% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, while the audience score is higher at 52%. This disparity highlights a divide between professional reviews and casual viewer enjoyment. For fans of Ritchson’s action performances or James’ comedic style, the movie may still provide a fun, albeit flawed, viewing experience.

The overwhelmingly negative reviews may affect Prime Video’s marketing strategy, emphasizing the star duo’s appeal over critical reception. In terms of genre trends, Playdate reinforces the ongoing challenges in balancing action and comedy in direct-to-streaming films, where audience engagement often outweighs critical acclaim.

Availability & Viewer Advice

Playdate is now streaming exclusively on Amazon Prime Video. Viewers interested in buddy-comedies or Ritchson and James’ performances may find entertainment despite critical warnings. Future projects for Alan Ritchson include the upcoming Reacher Season 4 in 2026, while Kevin James continues to explore family-oriented and comedy-focused roles.

Sources:

• Decider

• The Hollywood Reporter (THR)

• Paste Magazine

• AV Club

• CBR

• Amazon Prime Video