Wuthering Heights Fans React to Moviegoers Discovering Heathcliff and Cathy Are Toxic

The 2026 film adaptation of Wuthering Heights has sparked a wave of reactions from audiences who expected a sweeping romance but instead found themselves watching two deeply flawed characters unravel. Released over Valentine’s Day weekend and marketed as “inspired by the greatest love story of all time,” the movie left newcomers shocked by the toxic relationship at its core.

A Misunderstood Romance

While Emily Brontë’s novel has long been recognized as a gothic tale of obsession and cruelty, many first-time viewers assumed the film would deliver a tragic yet noble romance. Instead, Margot Robbie’s Cathy and Jacob Elordi’s Heathcliff embody selfishness, manipulation, and destructive passion. Their inability to communicate and their relentless torment of one another drive the story toward inevitable tragedy.

Fans Warn the Newcomers

Book readers quickly took to social media to remind audiences that Wuthering Heights is not a love story in the traditional sense. One fan wrote: “Run, Cathy! Run for your life, you silly girl! He’s a walking red flag!!!!!” Another added: “Did I miss something, or does everyone in this book suck?” The consensus among longtime readers is clear: the characters are fascinating, but they are far from admirable.

Polarizing Reactions

The film’s release has divided audiences. Some appreciate the adaptation’s faithfulness to Brontë’s vision of flawed humanity, while others feel misled by the romantic marketing. The “skin room” scene, in particular, has drawn criticism from viewers who found it unsettling.

Why It Resonates

Despite the discomfort, the story’s enduring power lies in its complexity. Cathy and Heathcliff are not heroes but deeply damaged individuals whose choices devastate themselves and those around them. Their toxic love is what makes Wuthering Heights a gothic masterpiece rather than a conventional romance.

Final Thoughts

Whether audiences love or hate the adaptation, one thing is certain: Wuthering Heights is not a fairytale. It is a cautionary tale about obsession, cruelty, and the destructive nature of unchecked passion. For those curious to experience the infamous story firsthand, the film is now playing in theaters.