Andy Cohen and John Hill Deliver Wild Holiday Humor on ‘Watch What Happens Live’

Key Points

• Andy Cohen and co-host John Hill reunited for a holiday-themed episode of Watch What Happens Live.
• Hill presented his annual “Top Five Holiday Wishes” for Cohen, filled with outrageous and comedic entries.
• The segment included playful references to pop culture, Real Housewives drama, and Cohen’s on-air persona.
• Cohen reacted with laughter throughout, especially to jokes tied to HBO Max’s Heated Rivalry.
• The long-running segment remains a fan favorite for its unpredictable, off-the-wall humor.

A Holiday Tradition Returns to the Bravo Clubhouse

Andy Cohen kicked off a festive episode of Watch What Happens Live by welcoming back his longtime co-host and friend John Hill. What followed was a signature blend of irreverent humor and holiday chaos as Hill unveiled his annual list of “Top Five Holiday Wishes” for Cohen—a tradition that has become one of the show’s most anticipated comedic bits.

The live audience erupted throughout the segment, which leaned heavily into Hill’s trademark mix of sharp wit, pop culture references, and playful jabs at Cohen.

John Hill’s Outrageous Countdown Begins

Hill opened the list with a tongue-in-cheek wish involving a holiday mishap, immediately setting the tone for the evening. His second entry blended classic seasonal imagery with a humorous twist, prompting Cohen to question the combination—only for Hill to volley back with a quick, cheeky retort.

The third wish referenced HBO Max’s Heated Rivalry, a series Cohen has openly enjoyed. Hill joked about Cohen being swept into the show’s dramatic world, to which Cohen enthusiastically replied, “That I can stand behind.”

A Nod to ‘Real Housewives’ Drama

Hill’s fourth wish took aim at the Real Housewives universe, suggesting Cohen be “visited by the ghosts of Housewives past, present, and presently suing him.” The line drew knowing laughter from the audience, acknowledging the franchise’s ongoing off-screen tensions.

A Finale Designed to Shock and Amuse

The top wish of the night arrived with a dramatic drumroll. Hill delivered a bold, comedic scenario involving Cohen and Times Square’s New Year’s Eve celebration—eliciting gasps, laughter, and raised eyebrows across the studio. Hill jokingly added that Anderson Cooper would be on standby to keep Cohen in line, referencing the duo’s famously spirited New Year’s broadcasts.

A Segment Known for Pushing Boundaries

This holiday countdown has become a staple of Watch What Happens Live, often veering into outrageous territory. Earlier this year, Hill jokingly suggested Cohen undergo cosmetic enhancements or release a long-rumored “vintage” tape—prompts Cohen met with his usual self-deprecating humor.

The chemistry between the two continues to be a major draw for viewers who tune in for candid conversations, celebrity antics, and unpredictable comedy.

What Happens Next?

Watch What Happens Live airs Sunday through Thursday at 10 p.m. ET on Bravo, with episodes streaming the next day on Peacock. As the holiday season continues, fans can expect more festive chaos, celebrity surprises, and the kind of unscripted moments that have made the show a late-night staple.