Actor Johnny Depp earned his first major acting break in 1984 with Wes Craven’s A Nightmare on Elm Street — but not because of his audition performance. According to casting director Annette Benson and Craven’s wife, Mimi Craven, the young musician’s poor reading nearly cost him the role. However, it was his looks — and a key reaction from Craven’s daughter — that ultimately convinced the director to cast him. The revelation offers a surprising glimpse into the early days of Depp’s Hollywood career.
In 1984, director Wes Craven was casting for his now-iconic horror film A Nightmare on Elm Street under New Line Cinema. A then-unknown Johnny Depp, primarily a musician, auditioned for the role of Glen Lantz — Nancy Thompson’s boyfriend. Despite a poor audition, Depp landed the part after Craven’s daughter and her friend insisted he was “dreamy” and perfect for the teen audience. The decision marked the beginning of Depp’s decades-long Hollywood career.
The Casting Decision
Casting director Annette Benson recalled that Depp’s agent, Ilene Feldman, had praised him highly, but Craven and his team were unconvinced after the audition. “He comes, he reads. He sucks. He wasn’t an actor,” Mimi Craven said. Initially, Wes Craven even crossed Depp’s name off the list. The turning point came when Craven’s teenage daughter and her friend reacted enthusiastically to Depp’s headshot, prompting the director to reconsider.
Quotes and Reactions
“They were squealing over him,” Mimi Craven told The Ringer. “Only dogs can hear that sound that young girls make. Annette and I looked at Wes — and that changed everything.”
Years later, Johnny Depp reflected on the experience, paying tribute to Craven at the Toronto International Film Festival in 2015. “At the time, I was a musician, not really an actor,” Depp said. “I always think of [Craven’s] daughter for putting me in this mess — and Wes for being brave enough to give me this gig.”
Career Turning Point
Depp’s appearance in A Nightmare on Elm Street became the launchpad for his film career, introducing him to Hollywood audiences and leading to future roles that cemented his reputation as a versatile actor. The story also highlights how instinctive decisions and public appeal can shape casting outcomes in the film industry. For Craven, the choice helped his film connect with younger audiences and further defined 1980s horror aesthetics.
What’s Next
While A Nightmare on Elm Street remains a classic, the behind-the-scenes anecdotes continue to fascinate film enthusiasts. With renewed interest in the franchise and Depp’s legacy, the revelation adds context to how an unplanned decision helped shape a Hollywood icon’s path.
Sources
The Ringer — Interview with Annette Benson and Mimi Craven
Variety — Johnny Depp’s tribute at TIFF 2015
Looper — Original coverage and background reporting
