A judge for the 74th Miss Universe pageant resigned just days before the Nov. 21, 2025, event following what he described as a “disrespectful conversation” and concerns over the competition’s transparency. Composer Omar Harfouch publicly announced his withdrawal via Instagram on Nov. 18, citing confusion over finalist selections and conflicts of interest among the judging panel. The Miss Universe Organization (MUO) refuted Harfouch’s claims, maintaining that all evaluations adhere to official protocols. This resignation comes amid broader scrutiny of the pageant, including recent controversy surrounding comments made by Miss Universe Thailand’s director.
Main Details
Omar Harfouch, a musician and judge for the Miss Universe pageant, raised multiple concerns about the selection process. He alleged that an “impromptu jury” selected finalists without the presence of the official eight-member judging panel, including himself. Harfouch also questioned possible personal relationships between committee members and contestants, suggesting a potential conflict of interest.
In response, the Miss Universe Organization clarified that Harfouch’s claims regarding an external or unauthorized jury were inaccurate. The organization confirmed that all evaluations follow established, supervised protocols and that the “Beyond the Crown” charity program operates independently from the competition.
Quotes and Reactions
Harfouch publicly explained his resignation on Instagram:
“I decided to resign from the jury and refuse to be part of this charade. I will also not be playing the music I composed for the event.”
He added that a “disrespectful conversation” with MUO president Raul Rocha regarding transparency motivated his decision.
The organization responded:
“Given Mr. Harfouch’s expressed confusion, his public mischaracterization of the program, and his stated desire not to participate, the Miss Universe Organization respectfully acknowledges his withdrawal from the official judging panel.”
The incident follows additional controversy, including remarks made by Miss Universe Thailand director Nawat Itsaragrisil, who called Miss Mexico, Fátima Bosch, “stupid” during a livestreamed event.
Impact Analysis
Harfouch’s resignation highlights ongoing challenges for the Miss Universe Organization in maintaining credibility and public trust ahead of the annual competition. While the pageant’s judging protocols remain intact, last-minute departures of prominent judges can influence perceptions of fairness. Analysts note that high-profile disputes may overshadow contestants’ performances and affect viewership engagement for the season finale.
This incident underscores the need for MUO to reinforce transparency and clarity in the selection process to preserve the integrity of the competition.
What’s Next
The 74th Miss Universe pageant will proceed on Nov. 21, 2025, with the remaining judging panel evaluating contestants. MUO has emphasized that all finalist selections and evaluations will continue according to established protocols.
Further announcements are expected regarding post-pageant responses to controversies, including detailed statements from judges or MUO leadership clarifying procedural steps and ensuring transparency for future competitions.
