Ashley Tisdale’s candid essay about leaving her mom group has ignited widespread conversation. Published on January 1, her piece titled “Breaking Up With My Toxic Mom Group” detailed feelings of exclusion and frustration, sparking speculation about the identities of the women involved.
Group Members Respond
While Tisdale did not name names, fans speculated that several high-profile Los Angeles moms — including Mandy Moore, Hilary Duff, and Meghan Trainor — were part of the circle. A source told Us Weekly that the group was “surprised” by the characterization and did not view the situation as toxic. According to the insider, the moms believed the friendship simply “faded organically.” They emphasized that “there was no big blowout moment” and that they never intended to hurt Tisdale. The group reportedly wishes her “no ill will” and maintains “there wasn’t any bad intent” behind the changing dynamic.
Tisdale’s Perspective
In her essay, Tisdale described noticing she was excluded from certain gatherings, often discovering them through social media. She wrote that the growing distance made her feel unwelcome, ultimately leading her to step away. The actress, who shares two daughters with husband Christopher French, said she eventually messaged the group to express her frustration before removing herself.
View this post on Instagram
Shifting Bonds Within the Circle
Another source suggested the tension may have stemmed from natural shifts in closeness. Some members reportedly grew tighter-knit due to overlapping schedules, shared interests, and similar parenting stages. These evolving bonds may have unintentionally left Tisdale feeling isolated, even though there was no deliberate effort to exclude her.
Reactions Beyond the Group
The situation drew reactions from adjacent circles. Hilary Duff’s husband, Matthew Koma, mocked the controversy with a satirical Instagram post. Meanwhile, Meghan Trainor denied involvement, joking on TikTok that she was “innocent.”
A Broader Conversation
Tisdale’s essay has sparked broader discussions about friendship dynamics among parents, particularly in high-profile communities. While her account resonated with many readers who have experienced similar feelings of exclusion, insiders insist the group never intended harm.
