Ryan Lizza has publicly expanded on allegations involving former fiancée Olivia Nuzzi and U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. The revelations surfaced in a new Substack post released Friday, where Lizza published an alleged poem Kennedy sent to Nuzzi during what he describes as a “digital affair.” The report raises serious questions regarding journalistic ethics, political conduct, and the credibility of past denials. The situation has also prompted renewed scrutiny of Nuzzi’s upcoming memoir and her professional standing within major media outlets.
What Happened and Who’s Involved
Lizza’s latest Substack release centers on a message he claims Kennedy sent to Nuzzi while she worked as a political reporter. The message—described by Lizza as a poem titled “American Canyon”—allegedly includes intimate language and imagery.
Kennedy, now serving as Secretary of Health and Human Services, has repeatedly denied any improper relationship with Nuzzi. Nuzzi previously acknowledged an undisclosed personal involvement with a source in 2024 but did not name Kennedy directly.
The controversy follows Lizza’s earlier claims this week alleging a separate affair between Nuzzi and former South Carolina governor Mark Sanford. Both incidents are now reportedly subject to internal review at Vanity Fair, where Nuzzi serves as West Coast Editor.
Quotes & Reactions from Analysts and Insiders
Lizza said he felt compelled to publish the information due to what he described as “misinformation” being circulated by Nuzzi and “denials by a consequential policymaker.”
“I wish I hadn’t been put in this position,” Lizza wrote. “But Bobby… is one of the most consequential policymakers in America. The least I can do is share the parts I believe you should know.”
Nuzzi’s legal counsel disputed the broader narrative:
Ari Wilkenfeld, attorney for Nuzzi, told The New York Times:
“In her memoir, Ms. Nuzzi discusses the only instance… in which she had an improper relationship with someone she was covering.”
Kennedy’s office has consistently denied the claims, reiterating he met Nuzzi only once professionally for an interview.
Analysts tracking political ethics say the allegations—if accurate—could further complicate oversight discussions already surrounding Kennedy’s tenure.
How This Affects Key Players
The fallout for Ryan Lizza, Olivia Nuzzi, and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. may carry significant implications:
For Kennedy:
The resurfaced allegations come at a sensitive time as he faces criticism over health policy decisions. Any perceived impropriety risks political consequences.For Nuzzi:
Her role at Vanity Fair may face heightened review amid questions about journalistic standards and undisclosed conflicts of interest.For Lizza:
The revelations place him at the center of a public conflict with two powerful figures, though his decision to publish may bolster his position among transparency advocates.
Media experts note that the timing—mere days before Nuzzi’s memoir release—intensifies public interest and scrutiny.
Upcoming Announcements & Timelines
Nuzzi’s memoir “American Canto” releases December 2, where she addresses at least one improper relationship from her career. It remains unclear whether the new allegations will prompt further revisions or public statements.
Vanity Fair is expected to complete its internal review in the coming weeks.
Kennedy’s office has not indicated any forthcoming statements beyond previous denials.
Lizza stated he may release additional documentation “if necessary,” suggesting more developments could follow.
As the situation evolves, Ryan Lizza’s report ensures the matter remains under investigation across both media and political circles.
The escalating dispute involving Ryan Lizza, Olivia Nuzzi, and RFK Jr. continues to raise questions about ethics, transparency, and political accountability. Lizza’s claims and Kennedy’s denials set the stage for further scrutiny as the public awaits additional evidence and upcoming statements. The controversy shows no signs of slowing as all parties brace for the next phase of revelations.
